2born (2born) wrote,

Исторический метод в обучении второму закону Кеплера

Уважаемый mi1kyway, это для вас:))

A Historical Method Approach to Teaching Kepler's 2nd law: https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.13386
Wladimir Lyra
Kepler's 2nd law, the law of the areas, is usually taught in passing, between the 1st and the 3rd laws, to be explained "later on" as a consequence of angular momentum conservation. The 1st and 3rd laws receive the bulk of attention; the 1st law because of the paradigm shift significance in overhauling the previous circular models with epicycles of both Ptolemy and Copernicus, the 3rd because of its convenience to the standard curriculum in having a simple mathematical statement that allows for quantitative homework assignments and exams. In this work I advance a method for teaching the 2nd law that combines the paradigm-shift significance of the 1st and the mathematical proclivity of the 3rd. The approach is rooted in the historical method, indeed, placed in its historical context, Kepler's 2nd is as revolutionary as the 1st: as the 1st law does away with the epicycle, the 2nd law does away with the equant. This way of teaching the 2nd law also formulates the "time=area" statement quantitatively, in the way of Kepler's equation, M = E - e sin E (relating mean anomaly M, eccentric anomaly E, and eccentricity e), where the left-hand side is time and the right-hand side is area. In doing so, it naturally paves the way to finishing the module with an active learning computational exercise, for instance, to calculate the timing and location of Mars' next opposition. This method is partially based on Kepler's original thought, and should thus best be applied to research-oriented students, such as junior and senior physics/astronomy undergraduates, or graduate students.
Comments: 15 pages main article, 3 pg appendix, 8+2 figures. Submitted to Astronomy Education Journal

Апдейт: еще образовательное по 2-му закону:

Keplers's Equation and Angular Momentum: Historical Perspective, Critical Analysis and Implications for Development of the Orbital Mechanics/Dynamics, Mathematics and Physics: https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.00749
Slobodan Nedić
After some more than four centuries from the formulation and publication (in Astronomia Nova) of the Kepler's Equation, which relates the eccentric (and, intermediately, the true) anomaly of the planetary trajectories to the uniformly flowing time, in accordance with his Second ("Area") law, the subsequently -- in course of development of Orbital Mechanics -- to the 2nd law related and formally derived non-existent (zero-valued) transverse acceleration is refuted. Certain implications to Elliptic Integration, Symplectic Integration, Symplectic Geometry/Topology, as well as the connection between physical and mathematical continua in the context of the multi-level, scale-invariant mechanics/dynamics (with the augmented central and torquing forces) are also briefly hinted to.
Tags: Мегаучебник или Что я читал и похвалил, образование, разгребая arXiv'ы

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.